On Monday evening, I was at the House of Commons to give evidence to the Commission of Inquiry into achieving best value in the procurement of construction work. I spoke mostly about the problems facing SMEs and about the difficulty many local authority clients face in procuring design services effectively.
The Commission is made up of several MPS and one peer, the Earl of Lytton, together with a number of senior figures from the construction sector, including Sir John Armitt, Jack Pringle and Alan Crane. What they are trying to find out is whether construction work is currently procured effectively, and, if it isn’t, what might be done about it.
If you appear to give evidence before a Select Committee you are given advance notice of the main questions, so you can prepare, but this kind of Commission does not follow those formal rules. So on Monday, I sat for an hour and half, together with a colleague from RICS and a colleagues from RIBA, and answered various googlies thrown at us by MPs and peers, as well as from other Commission members.
The hardest grilling, I felt, came not from the parliamentarians, who appeared to me to be genuinely and open-mindedly interested in trying to find ways of improving procurement. It came from the construction industry figures, who seemed pretty unconvinced that SMEs were disadvantaged by current procurement systems, and perhaps not terribly concerned if that was the case. Equally, both the LI and RIBA came under some pressure for arguing that, if you are procuring design services, it is difficult to make a good job of this without some client-side design expertise.
One way or another, the drive to squeeze down costs and speed up projects is on in earnest in the construction sector. The government has staked rather a lot on the general adoption of BIM across the construction professions by 2015 – they expect this to achieve a 20 per cent cost reduction as well as time savings on most public construction contracts.
The Chief Construction Adviser has not given any indications as yet that the public sector is going to push for particular forms of contract, but the Commission showed great interest in the RICS presentation about Performance-Related Partnering (PRP) and how it had been used, apparently to great effectiveness, to build hospitals in Northern Ireland. If any members have been involved in a project which used PRP and has any war stories to tell about it, please let me know. It would be a great shame if PRP emerges as a major recommendation in the Commission’s final report if LI members have had a bad experience with it.
In 2012, we will be redoubling our efforts to spread the message about landscape architecture and the benefits it brings...
'Kong’ is the character that defines 2011, according to a survey conducted across China by the Chinese Ministry of Education...
Read ‘The year of Kong’ in full
Do we spend too much time trying to innovate when we should design instead? This was one of the points raised at a very interesting debate at the Design Council last week, which considered the question ‘Should government have a design strategy’?
Read ‘Design, don’t innovate!’ in full
Since my last blog, the most thought-provoking thing I have heard is Kim Wilkie CMLI speaking at the panel discussion that concluded our series of talks at the Garden Museum...
Read ‘Soiling the city’ in full
In January this year, we started a new campaign called ‘Why Invest in Landscape?’, which makes a financial case for the benefits of retaining a landscape architect.
Read ‘Making the case for investment’ in full
Nice to be asked to do the guest blog while Alastair is away, and lucky that it’s been such a busy week for the LI giving me lots to talk about...
Read ‘Landscape in motion’ in full
Nearly ten months have passed since LI member Jo Yeates was killed, and the trial of Vincent Tabak has started at Bristol Crown Court...
Read ‘Remembering Jo Yeates’ in full
The week beginning 10 October will be a particularly important one for the LI...
Read ‘Government seeks LI views on planning’ in full
A very big thank you indeed this week to all of the practices who sent in case studies for our new Client’s Guide, which is due to be published early next year...
Read ‘New guide for clients in progress’ in full
How is it possible that we can tolerate public space so dire that a naff theme park in Japan is a nicer place to spend an afternoon than the centre of one of our great historic cities?
Read ‘Is Britain the world capital of drab?’ in full
The last couple of weeks have been a bit strange. Out of the blue, the world seemed to go completely mad...
Read ‘What is so odd about England?’ in full
Just after the terrible tsunami in March, I blogged about the only pine tree left standing in Rikuzentakata, but recent news from the town is not encouraging...
Read ‘Sole survivor faces a slow death’ in full
These were the momentous words of John Penrose MP, Minister for the Built Environment, speaking at the launch of RIBA’s new report.
Read ‘‘The public sector has been a dumb client for design’’ in full
Last week, it was reported that RIBA President Ruth Reed’s efforts to lobby government about the need to maintain and strengthen the professional training of architects were rebuffed with the remark that 'there are too many architects anyway’...
Read ‘Are there too many landscape architects?’ in full
I attended the Landscapes of the Future launch at the House of Commons this week, discussing not only the new ‘POST Note’ on the Future of Landscape but also the government’s first White Paper on the environment for 20 years...
Read ‘LI Policy Chair Noel Farrer writes this week’s blog’ in full
The Landscape Institute has raised the problems of procurement directly with government in recent months...
Read ‘Tackling procurement problems’ in full
I am pleased to report a second successful year for the LI in financial terms, with a second year-end surplus and our bank loan paid off more than two years early...
Read ‘A sound financial year’ in full
A point that has been raised with me at several branch events is about the need to review the Chartership exams...
Read ‘Help shape the Chartership exams’ in full
One of the towns that was obliterated by the tsunami in Japan was Rikuzentaka in Iwate Prefecture...
Read ‘The pine tree: a symbol of hope’ in full
Last week was dominated by the budget announcement, so I thought I would use this week’s blog to highlight a few points from it that are relevant to us...
Read ‘Remarks on the budget’ in full
This week I have added a picture to my blog. The reason being that this image shows a traditional form of landscape architecture that has been practised in Japan for many centuries...
Read ‘Support for Japan’ in full
On Wednesday, I spent the day at Ecobuild, where the LI was running our seminars to kick off the ‘Why Invest in Landscape?’ campaign...
Read ‘GI on the political agenda’ in full
By now I hope most members will have received their copy of the magazine, together with the ‘Why Invest in Landscape?’ leaflet...
Read ‘On the campaign trail’ in full
This week it became clear after many weeks of uncertainty that a slimmed down CABE is to merge with the Design Council...
Read ‘Ensuring the quality of public space’ in full
My reading over the holidays was Dame Sylvia Crowe’s The Landscape of Power, published in 1958 when the first generation of nuclear power stations was being built...
Read ‘A timely rereading of Sylvia Crowe’ in full
Before I set out my thoughts on the New Year, I should like to touch on the recent tragic events that resulted in the death of Jo Yeates, who was one of our members...
Read ‘President’s letter to members’ in full
Many congratulations to the new Chartered Landscape Architects who have just passed their exams. The results are out today and many candidates and their mentors will be breathing a big sigh of relief...
Read ‘Passing into the New Year’ in full
I usually don’t enjoy the Landscape Institute Awards that much. Others can relax and enjoy themselves while feasting on the tremendous visual spectacle of the year’s finest landscape schemes, but I am standing on stage with my back to the screen trying to remember how to pronounce Moel-y-Faen properly...
Read ‘Alastair McCapra at the Landscape Awards’ in full
This week I have been in Liverpool for the UK Landscape Awards and Conference. It was a really inspiring two days, beginning on Monday with the announcement of the winner of the UK Landscape Award...
Read ‘Alastair McCapra at the UKLA Awards’ in full
My iPhone app recommendation this week is called 'Fractals'. I'm pointing you towards it now because Benoit Mandelbrot, who coined the term fractal in 1975, died on 14 October...
Read ‘The power of design’ in full
As we welcome our 281st Twitter follower, it seems an appropriate point to pause and reflect on this new way of communicating. For me, there are three key things...
Read ‘The multiplier effect’ in full
I’m just back from the judging weekend for this year’s Landscape Institute Awards. More than a hundred entries this year, so no sign that the recession is dampening the ardour of our registered practices to put themselves forward...
Read ‘Setting the bar high’ in full
Being able to move into Charles Darwin House is really a fantastic opportunity for the Landscape Institute and, ultimately, we owe that opportunity to an LI member who is also a member of one of the organisations based in Charles Darwin House...
Read ‘A serendipitous encounter with Charles Darwin’ in full
Should a profession seek legal protection for its specialist fields of work? As a long recession begins to take its toll, many feel that protecting an area of professional expertise against cowboy operators is essential.
Read ‘Protect and survive?’ in full
It may be that preserving biodiversity is not the essential key to climate change adaptation. It may be, on the contrary, that climate change adaptation requires us to mutilate the landscape in order to maximise energy production, sacrificing biodiversity for electricity, and doing things that greens have always regarded with horror.
Read ‘The landscape dilemma’ in full
The last week of July saw the annual visit of our auditors, who left last Friday indicating that they have no adjustments to make to the trading figures in our accounts. After the difficulties of the 2008-9 period this is a tremendous relief. And the good news didn't stop there...
This month the coalition in Westminster continues to charge ahead, scattering quangos and trampling on projects at such a ferocious speed that it is hard to keep up. The Sustainable Development Commission is now to disappear, we learn, along with Building Schools for the Future.
Read ‘Bonfire of the quangos?’ in full
Many thanks to the members who responded to our recent survey ‘Our Future Profession’. The results have been discussed at Council and will be used as the basis for shaping our future strategy for the next 3–5 years. I will be posting a summary of the results on the website soon, together with some suggestions for what the implications are for the LI.
Read ‘Cutting red tape – getting better value’ in full
Most of yesterday’s budget was about raising taxes and cutting spending, but not everything in it was bad news for landscape architecture. The budget reaffirmed David Cameron’s commitment to making his administration the greenest government ever, and it contained a number of proposals that made it ‘moderately green’.
Read ‘The Budget – it’s not all bad’ in full
The new government’s programme continues to take shape, and so far there seems to be little reason for rejoicing among landscape architects.
Read ‘Future shock – future solutions’ in full
You will be aware of our communications survey which closes on Friday of this week. In addition to the opportunity to win £100 of Amazon vouchers, you will be giving us a great deal of help in planning our communications over the next couple of years.
Read ‘Monitoring the changing political and economic environment’ in full
As the new UK government starts to take shape, we have an interesting task on our hands. Though the full new cabinet has not been announced, Chris Huhne (LD) will be the new Energy and Climate Change Secretary and Eric Pickles (Con) will be Communities Secretary. It is not yet known who the Environment Secretary will be.
What will the landscape architecture profession look like in five years’ time? Does the traditional partnership model have a future? How much is the scope of landscape architects’ work going to change because of, or in spite of, the recession? What external factors are going to influence the future of the profession?
Read ‘Picturing the future’ in full
"It was the best of times, it was the worst of times..." These certainly are not the best of times, but are they the worst? Have we got past the worst already or are things set to improve over the coming year?
Read ‘The worst of times?’ in full
Today is the first day of the new financial year, so an appropriate moment to reflect on what has been achieved over the past 12 months.
Read ‘The year of green infrastructure’ in full
London taxi drivers are famous for their ability to navigate the capital’s maze of streets. In fact, neuroscientists discovered that the region of the brain called the hippocampus was larger in these cabbies than the average person. The LI has not yet suggested funding a similar study examining the brain capacity of the average landscape architect, if there is such a being, but it has provided a rich resource that will feed the mind.
Welcome to the updated website. Regular visitors will notice we have made some subtle, but significant changes. These have been implemented to make it more accessible for members and here are some of the highlights.
Read ‘Your feedback please’ in full